Alice Pearce: Going Through a Phase

Alice Pearce does not have the number of acting credits that many golden- age character actresses possess because she passed away at an early age. Many of us recognize her as Gladys Kravitz.

📷closerweekly.com

Pearce was born in New York City in 1917. She was an only child. Her father was a foreign banking specialist, and her family moved to Europe when she was a toddler. They had what I would imagine was a magical life, living in Brussels, Antwerp, Rome, and Paris. However, Alice was not a fan of Europe and never went back. In an article in the Buffalo News in July of 1965 she said that she hated living there and just wanted to be an average American kid who was allowed to walk to the movies or the drug store without a chaperone.

While living in Europe, she fell off a swing at age nine after losing her grip on the chain and landed on her chin. From that point on, she had an underdeveloped chin.

Pearce enrolled in Sarah Lawrence College in 1940, graduating with a degree in drama. After graduation, Alice moved to Maine to do summer stock. Leonard Stillman saw her there and cast her in “New Faces of 1943,” where she received great reviews.

Although her parents did not approve, Alice began working as a comedienne in nightclubs, auditioning on Broadway. Her parents didn’t know much about theater at the time, and they didn’t see it as a stable career. She moved to New York and sold underwear at Macy’s to make ends meet.

📷rottentomatoes On the Town

Alice always had a sense of humor about herself and her looks. She related a story in an interview with the Buffalo News in February of 1965 that during this time she and a few women performed at army camps and hospitals during the war. She said they were at a hospital one day and Imogene Coca was walking down the hall to do the show. One man in a bathrobe saw her and yelled that if they all looked like her, he was going back to bed. A minute later, Alice appeared. The man said they did all look alike and he went back to bed.

From 1944-46, she was a cast member in the original Broadway production, “On the Town.” Gene Kelly was so impressed with her performance that he brought her to Hollywood as a cast member in the big-screen film of the play in 1949. In both versions, Alice played Lucy Schmeeler, a “unsexy adenoidal” blind date.

Her performance in On the Town was so popular that she was given her own television variety show, The Alice Pearce Show which she described as “fifteen minutes of songs, topical skits, and me.” Pearce co-hosted the show with pianist Mark Lawrence. It was on for fifteen minutes every Friday, but it was cancelled after six episodes.

📷moviestillsdb.com The Disorderly Orderly

Throughout the fifties, Pearce continued to appear on Broadway and on the big screen. Alice had fourteen film roles.  She was spot-on as a hypochondriac in The Disorderly Orderly with Jerry Lewis as she describes her numerous physical ailments and symptoms.

I think Alice was hoping for a more prolific film career. After her death, an AP article that ran in many national papers related a story Pearce had told several times. She said that for one audition she went to, they were looking for an “Alice Pearce type,” so she thought it was a shoe in. About ten women were in the waiting room. Alice did her audition but didn’t get the part!

During the fifties, she appeared on 13 television series, many of them dramatic playhouse shows. In 1953, Alice was cast in two sitcoms, and both would last a year. In Jamie, she appeared in eight episodes as Annie Moakum. The show was about an orphan, Jamie, who lands in one “foster” home after another until he moves in with Aunt Laurie where he meets Grandpa; the two of them become best friends, sharing a variety of adventures.

In The Jean Carroll Show, Alice played their neighbor in six episodes. This show only lasted three months. It was a typical sitcom about Jean, her bumbling husband Herbie and her daughter who doesn’t even have a first name in the credits.

Alice found herself in sixteen series during the sixties including Many Happy Returns. Many Happy Returns was a show that only lasted 26 episodes. It starred John McGiver as Walter Burnley who was a supervisor of the Returns Department at Krockmeyer’s Department Store. A widower, he lives with this daughter played by Elinor Donahue and her husband Bob and daughter Laurie.

📷facebook.com

1964 was a great year for Pearce. When she was in the Broadway production of “Bells Are Ringing,” she met director Paul Davis whom she married in 1964. At that time, Davis owned one of the top art galleries in Los Angeles. Alice loved art and did some painting herself.

That same year she was asked to play the role of Grandmama in The Addams Family. She turned down the part which went to Blossom Rock.

It ended up being a good career move to turn down The Addams Family, because later in 1964 she was offered the role of Gladys Kravitz on Bewitched. She was perfect as the nosy neighbor always in the Stephens’ business. After spying on her neighbors and seeing something that could not be explained logically, she would shrilly yell, “Abner, Abner” and relate the newest situation. Of course, witchcraft always took care of the problem before she could prove anything odd had occurred, and she was considered eccentric and high strung by the other neighbors and her husband. Pearce appeared in 27 episodes before passing away from ovarian cancer in 1966 at age 48. She was adored by her Bewitched family.

Alice had been acting for a couple of decades and had become a household name. In the July 1965 Buffalo News interview, Alice mentioned that even though she was 47, her parents had moved to La Jolla, California and still felt acting was a phase she would outgrow.

In 1966, Doris Day’s movie The Glass Bottom Boat was released. Pearce and George Tobias were cast as next-door neighbors in the film. Although they weren’t named Gladys and Abner, the Fenimores were a carbon copy of the Kravitzes.

Alice was diagnosed with terminal cancer before she joined the Bewitched cast. After she died, Elizabeth Montgomery and her husband William Asher offered Davis a job as director on the show. He had stepped away from his career to help care for Alice.

Alice worked until the last two weeks of her life. She commented on how her attitude helped her deal with her diagnosis: “I feel the progress of the disease in my case is unusual because of my mental attitude. I am a supremely happy woman. I have never been beautiful, but I have been blessed with a rich career and the love of two fine men. The strength I have found in the devotion of my dear Paul is beyond measure.”

Frederick Turner wrote a book, Sweet Oddball: The Story of Alice Pearce. He recalled a quote that he had heard about Pearce, describing her as “’the adenoidal lass with the most beautiful, homely face on Broadway who carved out a unique career playing wallflowers, nitwits, nags and oddball characters.” I think Alice would be just fine with that description. Although she left us much too soon, she was an amazing comedienne who I’m sure would have had a long and satisfying career, and perhaps her own sitcom, had she lived a few more decades.

George Tobias: Following His Own Dream

As we learn about a few Bewitching characters this month, I had to include the Kravitzes, Abner and Gladys, a/k/a George Tobias and Alice Pearce. Today let’s take a closer look at the career of George Tobias.

📷pinterest.com The Kravitzes

Tobias was born in New York in 1901. He was the son of Russian-Jewish immigrants, and his parents were active in the Yiddish theatre. After his older brother joined them, they tried to discourage George from following in their footsteps. In a St. Louis Post Dispatch interview in 1940, Tobias said “They made up their minds very definitely that I was not going to spend my life nearly starving as they did. They wanted me to be a doctor or lawyer, but I knew from a very early age that I would follow the same career as my mother, father and brother . . . so whenever I got an acting job in between other jobs, I had to keep it from my family.”

At age 15, Tobias was in local productions, making his Broadway debut at age 23. In 1939, Warner Brothers offered him a contract, and he appeared in 65 big-screen productions during his career, including parts in This is the Army and Marjorie Morningstar. Tobias appeared in four Oscar Best Picture nominees: Ninotchka (1939), Sergeant York (1941), Yankee Doodle Dandy (1942), and Mildred Pierce (1945).

Tobias’s television career began in 1954 in Our Miss Brooks. He would go on to earn 34 additional television credits before he retired in 1977.

📷imdb.com With James Cagney in The Strawberry Blonde

His first cast role was in Hudson’s Bay playing Pierre Falcon in 1959. This show centered on Hudson’s Bay Company and its fur trade shortly after North America’s colonization. Trappers, explorers, Native Americans, and both the French and British navigate the territory, seeking fortune, fame, and adventure.

In 1960, he showed up as Penrose on season one of Adventures in Paradise in a show about the adventures of the Tiki III and crew as they sailed from island to island through the South Pacific, carrying cargo and the odd passenger from one drama to another.

From 1964-1971, Tobias was part of the Bewitched cast as Abner Kravitz. He put up with his wife Gladys despite thinking she was high strung, delusional, and just plain kookie.

In 1966, Doris Day’s movie The Glass Bottom Boat was released. Pearce and George Tobias were cast as next-door neighbors in the film. Although they weren’t named Gladys and Abner, the Fenimores were a carbon copy of the Kravitzes.

📷tvinsider.com 1946 Nobody Lives Forever

George’s last regular role was in The Waltons during seasons one and two when he played junkman Vernon Rutley.

While Tobias took on a few more roles before retiring, 1977 was his last year of acting, appearing on Tabitha when he reprised his role of Abner Kravitz. Tabitha was Darrin and Samantha’s daughter, now an adult.

Tobias passed away in 1980 from bladder cancer. He never married or had children, although he had a 40-year on-and-off relationship with actress Milicent Patrick. Patrick had an active career in entertainment from 1941-1961; she was also a commercial artist, fashion designer, and children’s book illustrator.

Even though Tobias was no longer living, he had one more adventure to journey through. The hearse with his body was stolen on its way to the mortuary. The car was in a fender-bender, and while the two drivers exchanged information, a carjacker made off with the hearse. The car and body were found shortly afterward.

📷pinterest.com

In his book, Bewitched Forever, Herbie J. Pilato discusses how rugged and tough Tobias was in real life. He said he was “quite the equestrian. He owned and trained many horses, loved to play polo, and was a volunteer mounted policeman.” David White, who played Larry Tate, told Pilato that George “was a sheriff out in Peach Blossom, California, where he lived. He had a badge and everything.”

I always like Abner and Gladys Kravitz. I’m happy Tobias stuck to his guns and continued with his acting career, despite his parents’ worries. It sounds like he had a happy and successful life.

Dick York: His Job Was Back-Breaking Work

This month we are learning about some Bewitching characters and their careers. Today we get to learn more about Dick York, the first actor to portray Darrin Stephens.

📷imdb.com the first Darrin Stephens

York was born in 1928 in Fort Wayne, Indiana, part of a working-class family; his father was a salesman, and his mother was a seamstress. During his younger years, the family relocated to Chicago, and at 15 he began acting on the radio in “That Brewster Boy.”

He would appear in hundreds of radio episodes and instructional films before heading to New York City in 1951 where he lived at the YMCA. In New York, he appeared on Broadway and then began his film career. That same year, York married Joan Alt. While he was doing the radio show “Jack Armstrong, All-American Boy,” they met when she came in to do a commercial.

In 1959, he was filming They Came to Cordura with Gary Cooper and Rita Hayworth when he suffered a back injury on the set. As York described it, “Gary Cooper and I were propelling a handcar carrying several wounded men down a railroad track. I was on the bottom stroke of this sort of teeter-totter mechanism that made the handcar run. I was just lifting the handle up as the director yelled ‘Cut’ and one of the wounded cast members reached up and grabbed the handle. Now, instead of lifting the expected weight, I was suddenly, jarringly, lifting his entire weight off the flatbed—180 pounds or so. The muscles along the right side of my back tore. They just snapped and let loose. And that was the start of it all: the pain, the painkillers, the addiction, the lost career.”

However, the injury didn’t catch up with him at that exact moment. A year later he was offered a role in Inherit the Wind. He would end up in ten films during his career, but it was television where he spent most of his time.

📷imdb.com The Twilight Zone

A couple of years later he was part of the cast of Going My Way for a season. His television career continued, and you’ll see him in episodes of The Twilight Zone, Dr. Kildare, Alfred Hitchcock Presents, Route 66, and Wagon Train, among others.

In 1964 he was offered the role that made him a house-hold name, Darrin Stephens on Bewitched. York was with the series for five years and was nominated for an Emmy in 1968. York was nominated along with Richard Benjamin from He and She and Brian Keith and Sebastian Cabot from Family Affair, but they were all beat by Don Adams from Get Smart.

His back caused him a lot of pain while on the Bewitched set. The crew constructed a wall where he could lean between scenes, but half-way through season three, he was diagnosed with a degenerative spine condition which often sent shooting pains through his body. Watching seasons three and four, Darrin often can be found lying down or on the couch in many of his scenes.

Things escalated during the fifth season. York fell ill with a temperature of 105 degrees. He was feeling awful but decided to try to get through a few scenes. He was sitting on a scaffolding with Maurice Evans, Samantha’s dad on the show, when he told a crew member that he thought he should get down. “He started to help me down and that’s the last thing I remember until I woke up on the floor. That’s about all I remember of the incident . . . I’d managed to bite a very large hole in the side of my tongue before they could pry my teeth apart.” While he was in the hospital, he and William Asher had the tough talk about his future, and he agreed he needed to quit; he was then replaced with Dick Sargent.

In his autobiography, York says the next 18 months found him bedridden and dependent on painkillers. He got off the meds, but it took six months. He was able to beat his addiction. He and Joan had five children that needed care.

📷wikipedia.com

The family struggled economically after his addiction. In the mid-seventies, a real estate investment of theirs failed, and they were forced to go on welfare. In the early eighties the couple moved to Michigan to help care for York’s mother-in-law; they were surviving on a $650 monthly pension from the Screen Actors Guild.

York always kept a positive attitude. While he was bedridden, he made phone calls to help raise money for the homeless. He said, “I’ve been blessed. I have no complaints. I’ve been surrounded by people in radio, on stage, and in motion pictures and television who love me. The things that have gone wrong have been simply physical things.” He tried to revive his career, appearing on Simon & Simon and Fantasy Island, but it was just too late.

In addition to his back issues, York smoked three packs of cigarettes a day, and he eventually was diagnosed with emphysema. By 1989, he needed oxygen to help him breathe. He passed away from complications of the disease in 1992 at the young age of 63.

What a sad and painful ending to such a promising career. It’s amazing that someone in that kind of torment could still reach out to help others and try to spin a positive attitude about what he was grateful for. Thank you, Dick York, for leaving us with 68 great roles and the chance to get to know Darrin Stephens.

Dick Sargent: It Took Him Five Years to Become Darrin Stephens

Welcome to February! This month we are learning about some Bewitching characters, four actors who appeared on the show Bewitched: Dick Sargent, Dick York, George Tobias, and Alice Pearce. We are beginning with Dick Sargent.

📷imdb.com Darrin #2

Richard Cox was born in California in 1930. He later changed his name to Dick Sargent for his career. Sargent’s mother, Ruth McNaughton, was an actress using the name Ruth Powell. His father was a manager for many famous Hollywood actors including Douglas Fairbanks and Erich von Stroheim.

Dick majored in drama at Stanford University, appearing in a couple of dozen plays with the Stanford Players. After graduation, he began his movie career with his first film, Prisoner of War in 1954 starring Ronald Reagan. He had small roles in 35 films during his career including Love Me Tender with Elvis Presley, Operation Petticoat with Cary Grant, and That Touch of Mink with Doris Day. 1954 was also the year he began his television career in I Married Joan. Sargent would go on to appear in another 78 series before his career ended.

In the sixties he had his first roles as a cast member. He was in One Happy Family in 1961, Broadside in 1964, and The Tammy Grimes Show in 1966.

📷imdb.com The Ghost and Mr. Chicken

He was cast as Darrin Stephens in Bewitched from 1969-1972.

Sargent was originally asked to play Darrin in the pilot of Bewitched, but he was under contract with Universal, so he had to turn it down. I will admit, he had great credentials and a great career, and I appreciated his acting ability and admired him for his charitable work, but to be honest, I never liked him as Darrin, much preferring Dick York. I felt the same way about Sandra Gould who replaced Alice Pearce; she was a fine actress, but she just wasn’t Gladys.

It was more than the fact that they were both replacements. Dick York just seemed to have all the great traits of Darrin, and I understood why Samantha fell in love with him, even when he was being stubborn and unreasonable. However, with Sargent, he seemed to have a touch of arrogance and impatience. I also think York’s mannerisms gave more depth to the role and provided more humor. However, I do think the writing was much better in the early years, so if Sargent had been free to accept the role from the beginning, maybe his character would have been more likable.

Sargent’s only other regular cast role came in 1984 in Down to Earth. There were a lot of weird plots on sitcoms in the eighties, and this was one of them. After being struck down by a trolley in 1925, Ethel MacDoogan, a flapper, waits in heaven for a chance to help a family and earn her wings. That chance arrives in the form of the Preston family with Sargent as the father.

In between 1972 and 1984 he continued his television roles appearing on I Dream of Jeannie, Here’s Lucy, Taxi, Alice, Fantasy Island, Charlie’s Angels, The Waltons, and Murder She Wrote.

Sargent was an advocate for many charities. He and Sally Struthers raised money for the Christian Children’s Fund. He also worked on behalf of Special Olympics, World Hunger, AIDS Project Los Angeles, and the American Foundation for AIDS Research.

Sargent was a closeted gay man for much of his career, but in 1991 on National Coming Out Day, he admitted that he was gay. He said he felt he had to open up because he was concerned about the high rate of suicide among young, gay men. Sargent said when he finally came out at age 61, “It was such a relief. I lived in fear of being found out. Now it’s given me a whole new mission in life.”

📷threads.com

In 1989, Sargent was diagnosed with prostate cancer and passed away five years later.

Despite my preference for Dick York as Darrin, Sargent had an amazing career. He was able to continue in both film and television until he passed away in 1989. He gave back to the community and tried to make the world better for children, which I greatly appreciate. Whether you prefer York or Sargent, they were both Bewitching characters who helped make the show a favorite for decades.